0
Prologue or opening chapter necessity test
I have a prologue (or a short opening chapter set apart from the main narrative) and I'm not sure it's earning its place. Evaluate it honestly.
Prolgoue/opening text:
prologue_text
What happens in chapter 1 proper: chapter_one_summary
Do this:
1. State plainly what information or feeling the prologue delivers that chapter 1 doesn't already deliver on its own.
2. Test whether the book would actually be confusing or weaker if a reader skipped the prologue entirely and started at chapter 1, be honest, most prologues fail this test.
3. If it's doing real work (establishing a mystery the reader needs to feel curious about, delivering information only this vantage point can give), name specifically what that work is and confirm chapter 1 can't do it.
4. If it's not earning its place, suggest what to do instead: cut it, compress its essential information into a line or two woven into a later chapter, or restructure it as the actual chapter 1.
5. Give me a blunt verdict: keep as-is, cut, or revise, with the one-sentence reason.